Freedmen a fed issue

Discussion

June 12, 2009

Anonymous The Tahlequah Daily Press Fri Jun 12, 2009, 11:58 AM CDT

Editor, Daily Press:

The disparate racial treatment of Native American Freedmen began and must end with Congress, not the courts.

Congress created the Dawes Rolls under the Allotment Act of 1887 to document tribal citizenship. The rolls discriminated against African-Native American offspring by labeling them Freedmen without documenting degree of Native American ancestry. Interracial Caucasian Native American offspring were identified by blood quantum to 1/32nd degree, creating a “paper bag” test for Native American identity, and reinforcing the stigma against anyone “tainted” by African blood.

Freedmen challenged their segregation from “Indians by Blood,” but in 1906 Congress barred the transfer of Freedmen to the “by-blood” rolls. Thus began a century of Freedmen litigation seeking equality with “Indians-by-Blood,” who were granted the advantage of using the Dawes Rolls for documenting lineage. Congress inflamed racial tensions by apportioning government benefits based on blood quantum rather than treaties and the historical context from which they arose. For example, Congress excluded Seminole Freedmen in apportioning money between Florida and Oklahoma Seminoles in the Seminole Indians Judgment Funds Act of 1990. This fractured relations between Oklahoman Seminole Freedmen and Seminole-by-Bloods, which ended with the BIA siding with tribal leaders in denying Freedmen their share.

The treatment of Seminole Freedmen underscores the arbitrary character of the Dawes Rolls. The Seminole Tribe coalesced in Florida from escaped slaves and indigenous peoples disenchanted with the Southern plantation system of slavery. Escaped slaves intermarried within Seminole society, and shared African methods of crop cultivation more suitable to Florida’s climate. Even Congress recognized their integral role, and unlike the Cherokee, Chickasaw, Choctaw, and Creek, there was no legislative mandate to create separate rolls for Seminole Freedmen.

The issue is neither sovereignty nor blood quantum, but a core premise of the 14th Amendment: that when the government creates a discriminatory harm because of race, it has a duty to repair the lasting effects of that harm. In this instance, the harm is more insidious due to the initial bonding between African and Native Americans, and their common heritage as the two “involuntary” minorities.

Congress can facilitate the healing by reforming the law. First, the racial discrimination of the rolls must be repealed by affording all Freedmen Native Americans identical access to government benefits for “by-blood” Native Americans. Second, Congress must remove the economics underlying bias against Freedmen and increase grants to reflect full Freedmen citizenship. Only then can traditional tribal values be rescued from a blood fetishism fueled by perverse incentives that pit one disadvantaged group against another.

There is a certain irony in the fact that our founding fathers were inspired by the color-blind, egalitarian values of indigenous Americans, yet later legislated racial strife into the tribes in a way that persists.

Kevin James, Esq.

Former Columbia University Revson Fellow, New York

Text Only

Letters to editor

River car case closed
I just wanted to finish up the story of “Car in river.”

March 7, 2012
Make sure you vote
It’s that time of the year again – time for the school board to extend a two-year contract to three years. It seems the board is much more interested in the job security of [Superintendent] Shannon Goodsell than for the teachers and staff.

February 2, 2012
Ego influencing justice
Last year’s incident in the jail where inmate Daniel Bosh received significant injuries from what appears to be an attack by a jail employee serves as a reminder that we have flaws in our justice system.

February 2, 2012
Harnessing talents
Women met Tuesday, Jan. 17, who believe in the values of a strong U.S. Constitutional government, with more power in the state and local government; women who believe our federal government is spending out of control, to the point of pushing our nation into the poor house. We call ourselves conservatives.

January 30, 2012
Flip-flopping on issues
Shannon Goodsell, superintendent of Tahlequah Public Schools, apparently can’t make up his mind when it comes to giving taxpayer money to private organizations.

November 23, 2011
Thieves target cross
I am writing you regarding my cousin’s memorial cross on State Highway 51. He has been gone for four years now. The week before the four-year anniversary of his passing, someone stole his cross.

November 23, 2011
Kudos to the City Council
Editor, Daily Press:
Our elected officials showed wise judgment at [last] Monday’s City Council meeting. They chose individualism over collectivism.

November 7, 2011
Scare tactics on aliens?
Editor, Daily Press:
I just finished watching scare tactics on a new channel called the Curiosity Channel, on satellite television. It was about, “What would we do if we were attacked by beings from outer space?” It was, in my opinion, designed and produced by the big corporations who are now running the world.

November 7, 2011
Think twice about testing
Editor, Daily Press:
I do not condone the use of drugs by welfare recipients and I do not believe that many can afford to use drugs. I also do not condone government intrusion into the private lives of citizens.

November 7, 2011
No tax for B&GC
Reader Everett Childers argues there are better ways to fund the program.

October 31, 2011
More Letters to editor Headlines

What do you plan to do over the Memorial Day weekend?

Letters to editor

Search Results

Discussion

Freedmen a fed issue

What do you plan to do over the Memorial Day weekend?

Site Map

Contact Us