SB 834 bad for students, parents and teachers

Editorials

Discussion

April 7, 2009

By Chuck Pack The Tahlequah Daily Press Tue Apr 07, 2009, 11:04 AM CDT

You may have heard about the so-called School District Em-powerment Act (SB 834), authored by Sen. John Ford, R-Bartlesville, that recently passed the Oklahoma State Senate. Those who are pushing for its passage claim the bill will allow local school districts to ignore mandates that get in the way of quality education. However, proponent legislators have a difficult time pinpointing just how our students will benefit from this drastic overhaul of the public school system.

As written, SB 834 would give every school district in the state the right to deregulate. The bill would allow school districts to fall under the Charter School Act and pick and choose the mandates they want to meet. That’s right – no accountability and no transparency for patrons. Remember how deregulation got us into trouble on Wall Street? Why would we want that in our schools?

Ironically, while this bill sailed through the Senate and appears headed for the House floor, legislators continue to pass mandates they think schools should be following. If these new mandates are so important, why are they also trying to eliminate requirements to meet school law?

If enacted, schools would not be required to hire certified teachers, counselors, or librarians. Class sizes conducive to an effective learning environment, as mandated by HB 1017 (passed in 1990), could be easily ignored. How does removing these requirements improve the quality of a child’s education?

School boards already have the ability to opt out of mandates through the Development of Educational Improvement Plan, a provision that allows schools to be as innovative as they’d like. The Tahlequah Board of Education and the Tahlequah Education Association maintain a very positive working relationship that benefits our students and teachers. However, the Oklahoma State School Boards Association has come out in favor of the SB 834 with the belief that school boards should have “local control” and be able to fire a teacher at will.

Let’s take a look at history for a moment. Prior to the enactment of due process in public schools, a school board member who had a personal complaint against a teacher or a coach could use the power of the board to fire that individual for personal reasons, even if that person was considered a good teacher. Since then, Oklahoma courts have expressly recognized the public function served by the statutory tenure/due process scheme, which “promotes good order and the welfare of the state and school system by preventing the removal of capable and experienced teachers for reasons arising solely from political or personal whim” (Babb v. Independent School District No. I-5.829 P.2d 973 n.14 [Okla. 1992]).

Obviously, SB 834 is more about eliminating due process than improving the quality of our children’s education.

Our children deserve certified teachers and school counselors who have working conditions conducive to a positive learning environment. And Oklahoma teachers deserve the respect due process provides them. Remember, a teacher’s working environment is the student’s learning environment. These types of deregulations would do little to improve schools and in the end would cause our school boards to deal with more and more personnel issues.

I call on the Oklahoma Legislature and Gov. Brad Henry to join with Sen. Jim Wilson and Rep. Mike Brown to stop passage of this bad piece of legislation.

Those interested should contact Rep. Tad Jones, R-Claremore, who is the principal House author, to let him know their thoughts. He is the Majority Floor Leader and therefore determines what bills are heard each legislative day. He can be reached at (800) 522-8502, extension 380.

Do we want to lose good teachers to a political or personal whim? Do we want to completely dismantle a system that is the cornerstone of our democracy? Does SB 834 help Oklahoma’s children? I don’t think so.

Chuck Pack is a National Board Certified Teacher and serves on the OEA Board of Directors. He teaches math at Tahlequah High School.

Text Only

Editorials

Earmarks by Inhofe, others aren’t right
That smell in the air might not be bacon frying in your kitchen, but the unfolding of another porky project for an Oklahoma politician.

February 10, 2012
Press release deadlines for candidates
If you are running for a political office for which Cherokee County voters can cast ballots, it’s not too early to be thinking about a press release announcing your candidacy. Indeed, some have announcements already appeared in the Daily Press.

February 8, 2012
Superintendent pay: Freeze it
Rep. Jason Nelson, R-Oklahoma City, may not have planned to seek hero status; perhaps his action was even designed to make up for past legislative offenses. Either way, he’s about to become the darling of the moment for many Oklahomans who believe certain public school superintendents make far too much money.
Nelson is calling for a freeze on superintendents’ salaries, and rightly so.

February 6, 2012
Is your stuff not getting published?
If you’re a regular contributor to the “news” side of the Daily Press, we hope you haven’t noticed anything missing lately – like copy or photos you’ve submitted to us for publication. But if you have, there’s a good reason why, and there’s something you can do about it.

February 2, 2012
Cast your ballot, for children’s sake
As the old saying goes, if you don’t vote, you don’t have a right to complain about what you get.

January 18, 2012
Do your part to help THS senior party
Graduation from high school is a rite of passage – for many young people, the first major milestone in their lives. It signifies the end of childhood, and the crossing of the threshold into adulthood, although the newly minted adults still won’t be old enough to drink for another couple of years.

January 14, 2012
Drivers must stop for all school buses
Earlier this week, an 11-year-old boy was struck by a car after he got off a school bus on Downing Street. Fortunately, the boy wasn’t gravely injured, but he could have been.

January 13, 2012
Service unappreciated
It has become evident that the sentiment, “thank you for your service,” is an empty one when it comes to the medical profession.

January 13, 2012
Grateful to Kiwanis
I would like to let Tahlequah and Cherokee County know how grateful we are for the home improvements made by the Kiwanis Club and other volunteers.

January 13, 2012
Alcohol policy a sound idea
Recently, the Tahlequah City Council denied for the second time a request by Tom Barlow to host a wine-tasting and beer garden this fall as part of his annual Art of Living festival in Norris Park.

January 11, 2012
More Editorials Headlines

Tax-filing season is upon us. Which best describes your course of action?

Editorials

Search Results

Discussion

SB 834 bad for students, parents and teachers

Tax-filing season is upon us. Which best describes your course of action?

Site Map

Contact Us